A case control study on
Exposure to Hair Dye and the Goiter among Women attending Thyro
Care Clinic, Karur District, Tamilnadu
Mrs. G. Maheswari
PhD Scholar, Saveetha
University, Chennai
*Corresponding Author Email: mahipraneeth@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
Background: Among all endocrine disorders thyroid
disorders are more common in India. Unfortunately people were not much aware
about the causes and impact of thyroid diseases. Methods: The case control
research design would be carried out on 300 purposively selected women who were
attending Thyro Care Clinic, Karur
District to assess the association between exposure to hair dye and the Goiter
among women.
Results: The result showed that the calculated
chi-square value (82.5) is more than the table value (3.84) for 1 degree of
freedom at 0.05 level of significant. It
reveals that there was strong association between the Exposure to hair dye and
the goiter. The incident rate among exposed to hair dye was 52% and 5.8% among
non exposed to hair dyes. The relative risk goiter among women exposed goiter
was 8.96. The odds ratio shows that a risk of having the goiter among women
exposed to hair dyes was 17.5 times higher than those who did not exposed to
hair dyes.
Conclusion: The result confirmed that there was an
significant association between the Exposure to hair dye and the goiter among
women attending Thyro Care Clinic, Karur. This helps to
conclude that the long term use of hair dye
is one of the main risk factor for Goiter among Women.
KEYWORDS: hair dye, goiter,
women, Thyro care clinic, Karur
District, Tamilnadu.
INTRODUCTION:
A goiter from
the Latin gutteria, struma) is
a swelling of the neck or larynx resulting from enlargement of the thyroid gland (thyromegaly),
associated with a thyroid gland that is not functioning properly.
(en.wikipedia.org).
The burden of thyroid disease in the general
population is enormous. Thyroid disorders are the most common among all the
endocrine diseases in India.
In studies from western literature as many
as 50% of people in the community have microscopic nodules, 3.5% have occult
papillary carcinoma, 15% have palpable goiters, 10% demonstrate an abnormal
thyroid-stimulating hormone level, and 5% of women have overt hypothyroidism or
hyperthyroidism. (Mathew John, 2008).
A cross-sectional study was conducted to
assess the knowledge, practice, perception and adverse reactions among hair dye
users among patients, their attendees and staff of SDUMC. A questionnaire (28)
pertaining to use of hair dyes and reactions to them was administered randomly.
The demographic data are expressed as mean ± standard deviation, quantitative
data expressed as percentages. A total of 263 volunteers responded of which
52.5% and 47.5% were females and males respectively with mean age of 32.40 ±
6.01 years. The participants started using hair dye at an age of 27 (±3.63)
years. Synthetic dyes were used by 91%. Frequency of use in a year was 2-5
times in 51%. Instruction of the package insert was followed by 63.5%. Skin
test was never performed in 34% prior to their use. Nearly 96% expressed hair
dyeing was unsafe during pregnancy, lactation and in children. Adverse
reactions were reported by 42%, with headache (63%) and itching (38%) being the
most common. Hair dyeing was started at very early age. Majority used
semi-permanent dyes even though they perceived natural dyes were safe. They
continued dyeing despite adverse reactions, which indicates cosmetic
importance.
Dharmistha Patel, Sarala Narayana, Bhuvana Krishnaswamy, 2013:
Chemically, resorcinol is a dihydroxy
benzene. Benzene is a natural constituent of crude oil, and one of the most
basic petrochemicals. Benzene is also known to increase risk of cancer and
other illnesses. Scientists use benzene along with other chemicals to make
resorcinol, or they may fuse resins with potassium hydroxide to make it. In
hair color products, resorcinol works with other chemicals in the formula to
provide a permanent color effect. Particularly colors with more yellow tones
use resorcinol, though it can exist in any coloring product. (http://www.annmariegianni.com).
NEED FOR THE
STUDY:
According to the World Health Organization
(WHO), animal studies show that resorcinol caused thyroid dysfunction, effects
on the central nervous system, and alterations in the adrenal glands. The
organization adds that the ingredient was highly toxic after oral or
subcutaneous (under the skin) administration. The laboratory studies showed
that high doses of resorcinol inhibited thyroid peroxidase
enzymes, disrupting thyroid hormone synthesis and causing changes in the
thyroid gland that were consistent with goiter—thyroid enlargement. This
condition causes difficulties in regulating metabolism, which can result in
weight gain, malnutrition, and immune system dysfunction (http://www.annmariegianni.com).
Many people in
India now started to use hair dye. It is shocking news that more than one third
of women in India over age of 20 years started to use hair dye but having less
awareness about side effects of these hair dyes. The researcher would hear the
association between the hair dye usage and goiter and had interest to prove
scientifically. So the researcher had intention to measure the association
between the use of hair dye and presence of Goiter.
STATEMENT
OF THE PROBLEM:
A case control study on Exposure to hair
dye and the goiter among women
attending Thyro Care Clinic, Karur
District, Tamilnadu.
OBJECTIVES:
1. To find out the association between the
Exposure to hair dye and the goiter
among women attending Thyro Care Clinic, Karur District
2.
To
identify the risk of Goitre those who were exposure to hair dye among women attending Thyro
Care Clinic, Karur District.
HYPOTHESIS:
H1: There
is a significant association between the Exposure to hair dye and the goiter among women attending Thyro Care Clinic, Karur District.
H2 : There
is a significant risk of Goitre those who were exposure to hair dye among women attending Thyro
Care Clinic, Karur District.
RESEARCH
METHODOLOGY:
·
The
research design: The case
control design was used
·
Setting of the study: Conducted at Thyro Care Clinic, Karur District
·
Research
variable: Exposure to hair
dye and the goiter
·
Sample: women attending Thyro
Care Clinic, Karur District.
·
Sample Size: The total sample size is 300
·
Sampling technique: Purposive sampling technique was used.
RESULTS:
Table.1. Frequency and percentage
distribution of presence of goiter among women attending Thyro
Care Clinic, Karur District
|
Presence of goiter |
Frequency |
Percentage |
|
Yes |
68 |
23% |
|
No |
232 |
77% |
|
Total |
300 |
100% |
Figure 1. The cone diagram showing the
percentage distribution of goiter among women
Table.2. Frequency and percentage
distribution of exposure to hair dye among women attending Thyro
Care Clinic, Karur District
|
Exposure to hair dye |
Frequency |
Percentage |
|
Yes |
110 |
37% |
|
No |
190 |
63% |
|
Total |
300 |
100% |
Figure2. The cylinder diagram showing the
percentage distribution of women exposure to hair dye
Table .3. Showed that the association
between the Exposure to hair dye and
the goiter among women attending Thyro Care Clinic, Karur District.
|
Purposively selected samples |
Exposure to hair dye |
Total |
CV |
TV |
||
|
Presence of Goiter |
|
Yes |
No |
|
|
|
|
Yes (cases) |
57 |
11 |
68 |
82.5 |
3.84 |
|
|
No
(control) |
53 |
179 |
232 |
|||
|
Total |
|
110 |
190 |
300 |
||
P < 0.05 Not
significant
The table shows the calculated chi-square
value (82.5) is more than the table value (3.84) for 1 degree of freedom at
0.05 level of significant. It reveals
that there was strong association between the Exposure to hair dye and the goiter among women attending Thyro Care Clinic, Karur
District.
Table.4. Contingency table applied to Exposure
to hair dye and the goiter among women
attending Thyro Care
Clinic, Karur District.
|
Purposively selected samples |
Exposure to hair dye |
Total |
||
|
Presence of
Goiter |
|
Yes |
No |
|
|
Yes (cases) |
57 |
11 |
68 |
|
|
No
(control) |
53 |
179 |
232 |
|
|
Total |
|
110 |
190 |
300 |
Exposure rates:
Incidence among exposed: a/a+c = 57/110 = 0.518 x 100= 52%
Incidence among non exposed: 11/190
= 0.0578x100 = 5.8%
Relative risk:
Incidence among exposed / Incidence among
non exposed
52/5.8 = 8.96
Odds ratio
=
ad/bc
=
57x179/ 11x 53
=
10203/583
= 17.5
The table. 4. Shows that the frequency of exposure to
hair dye and frequency of goiter among women attending Thyro
Care Clinic, Karur. The incident rate among exposed
to hair dye was 52% and 5.8% among non exposed to hair dyes. The relative risk
goiter among women exposed goiter was 8.96.
The odds
ratio shows that a risk of having the goiter among women exposed to hair
dyes was 17.5 times higher than those who did not exposed to hair dyes.
DISCUSSION:
Objective
1: To find out the
association between the Exposure to hair dye and the goiter among women attending Thyro
Care Clinic, Karur District.
Table. 3. The table shows the calculated chi-square
value (82.5) is more than the table value (3.84) for 1 degree of freedom at
0.05 level of significant. It reveals
that there was strong association between the Exposure to hair dye and the goiter among women attending Thyro Care Clinic, Karur
District.
So the first hypothesis (H1)
“There is a significant association between the Exposure to hair dye and the goiter among women attending Thyro Care Clinic, Karur District”
was accepted.
Objective 2:
To identify the risk of Goitre those who were exposure to hair dye among women attending Thyro Care Clinic, Karur District
The incident rate among exposed to hair
dye was 52% and 5.8% among non exposed
to hair dyes. The relative risk goiter among women exposed goiter was 8.96. The
odds ratio shows that a risk of
having the goiter among women exposed to hair dyes was 17.5 times higher than
those who did not exposed to hair dyes.
So the second hypothesis (H2) “There is a significant risk of Goitre those who were exposure to hair dye among women attending Thyro Care Clinic, Karur District” was accepted.
IMPLICATIONS
FOR NURSING:
·
The
nursing personnel working in hospital and community settings can reinforce the
side effects of hair dye and its impact on thyroid.
·
Nursing
educator can educate the nursing professionals about the importance of
screening for learning disabilities for protecting the child from social stress
in order to make the healthy society.
·
Nursing
educator can influence the society and can create awareness about chemical hair
dyes.
·
The study may be issued for further reference.
·
Dissemination
of results can create awareness among common public which helps to avoid
complications due to chemicals in hair dye.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
·
The
similar study can be conducted with large samples
·
The
similar study can be conducted by comparing the different products of cosmetic
dyes
·
This
similar study can be replicated on large scale there by findings can be
generalized for the target population.
·
A
similar study can be done among hair dressers and other professionals those who
are continuously exposed to hair dye.
REFERENCES:
1. http://www.apiindia.org/pdf/medicine_update_2008
2. www.en.wikipedia.org
3. International Journal of
Trichology. 2013 Jul-Sep; 5(3): 140–143,
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
4.
http://www.annmariegianni.com
Received on 23.11.2015 Modified on 29.11.2015
Accepted on 08.12.2015 ©
A&V Publications all right reserved
Int.
J. Nur. Edu. and Research.2016;
4(2):103-106.
DOI: 10.5958/2454-2660.2016.00023.5